LENTEN SERIES 6 – 4 April 2004 – Bishop Owen Dowling   

WANTING WHAT ISN’T MINE   (Commandment 10 ‘You shall not covet’) 

I’ve surprised myself. This series on the Ten Commandments ends today, and in relation to each of them I haven’t had any trouble in thinking of issues that relate – relate to the Commandments and relate to our lives. They’re not old addresses and they’re not old issues. I hope you’ve been surprised too. 

Coveting, not a word in everyday language, is very much a contemporary sin. It means wanting what belongs to ;wanting, not in a moderate way, but with a depth of jealous desire that directs and controls us. 

The coveting commandment takes us inwards. On the surface, the other commandments seem to be about outward behaviour – the way we speak about God and other people, and the way we treat them, and do or do not honour or respect them and what properly belongs to them. The one we follow did however focus on the importance of our inner thoughts, especially, we noted, in relation to murder and adultery, in ways that make us feel uncomfortable. This no doubt explains why the church’s liturgy has always talked about sins in thought, word and deed. But the 10th commandment, the one about coveting, is the commandment par excellence about inward thoughts, except for the 2nd commandment, the one about idolatry (pardon, any Roman Catholic readers or hearers – for you it’s part of the 1st commandment). We can erect idols in our heart and mind and theycan dominate us from within. So the 2nd and the 10th commandments are alike in their inwardness. St. Paul takes it further – he says that covetousness is idolatry. In either case, an image forms in our mind and we feed it, we indulge in it, we let it dominate us and our lives. 

Advertising, which has a highly intrusive place in our world, is, of course, almost entirely based on our coveting and jealous instincts. I want what I see. I want what the beautiful successful people have; I can’t live without it. I want their body, their biceps, their exciting jet-setting lifestyle, their health, or their beautiful care-ree retirement with interesting friends always visiting. I want that BMW convertible over the road (-there is one opposite our place!). The more I go on the more you will say this sermon is telling us more about you than us and our temptations! So you do some application for yourself. What are your fantasies in life? What drives you on? What makes you feel very discontented with yourself? What cruel blows have made you wish that you were someone else or someplace else? 

It is, of course, a matter of degree. All of us have some harmless fantasies and things on our wish-list which colours up our sometimes drab lives. Who would deny us a little fantasy, a touch of dreaming? I suppose God isn’t going to come down on us with a heavy hand or a rumble of thunder because we go and buy a lottery ticket and have a distant thought of a house in Southern France, or even dispersing some largesse to our children or grandchildren. These may be but momentary thoughts. 

I can, however, think of parts of peoples’ lives I have known, even parts of my own life when there has been an invasion of quite serious bouts of covetousness. 

I think of a curate I once know – a good looking kindly warm caring person who led a Young Adults group. One of the girls in that group – a rather needy person – fell in love with him, but he didn’t with her. Nothing could convince her that he didn’t love her; because he was kind and tender with all the group, he treated her the same. She was convinced, even convinced in her prayers and dreams – and she did have a very deep and committed faith – that he must love her and desire to have her as his wife and partner in the walk of the ministry. I won’t go on, but it was for her an obsession she could not shake off. It affected the whole of her life as she waited at home for his call, and all this despite very open and direct speaking to her on his part, and her friends’ part.

To use another church illustration – it is after all a world I’ve been very familiar with for most of my 70 years – I have always worried about those clergy whose names get mentioned in connection with a possible bishop’s appointment. They may get rung up and asked whether they will let their name go forward. Then the fantasies begin – what would it be like to be the Bishop of So and So. Loud protests and denials such as ‘wouldn’t want to be a bishop!’ don’t deceive. The heart goes after position, honour and for the high church person at least – what kind of cope will I have made, how high should my mitre be? I know – I’ve been through it. But what is worse it’s hard to focus on the present ministry you have when you spend a lot of time thinking ahead to the glory (?) which is to come. 

Progress in any profession is attended by these temptations and difficulties. One friend of mine who’s now out of the ministry had great difficulty in handling several rejections in Episcopal elections. Only one gets the prize and the other candidates have to handle this seeming rejection. He was very hurt, and thought he wasn’t wanted. 

You may well be thinking to yourself – well, isn’t there a proper kind of ambition? Shouldn’t we put ourselves forward, so others at least know of our gifts and can draw on them. In the competition for high office, I must admit the church has the best and the worst of the world of ambition. Best in the sense that there are some genuinely humble servants of the Lord who would try to measure whether there was an element of ‘call’ and appropriate giftedness in considering whether to say yes to a particular offer; worst, in the sense that no one is supposed to be ambitions for high office, and we are. 

It must be pretty tricky in the parliamentary political parties. To aspire to leadership is not a bad thing. It’s the methods of getting there that we might question, and the deceit and back-stabbing that often seems to be involved. Covetousness very often leads to other sins. 

I said earlier – it is a matter of degree. There is a proper kind of ambition. The ambition to make the most of yourself and your life is a good thing – an important part of your own stewardship. We don’t have to be withering violets, always putting ourselves in the background, always saying ‘Oh you wouldn’t want me’. Coveting is wanting what doesn’t properly belong to us. Always wanting and jealously viewing what others have gained. Hating them for their success, their promotion and their increased prosperity. 

There’s a saying in the bible which links godliness and contentment. It’s from 1 Timothy 6:6-10 and they’re wise words:

‘There is great gain in godliness combined with contentment; for we brought nothing into this world, so we can take nothing out of it; but if we have good and clothing, we will be content with these. But those who want to be rich fall into temptation and are trapped by many senseless and harmful desires that plunge people into ruin and destruction. For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil, and in their eagerness to be rich some have wandered away from the faith and pierced themselves with many pains.’ 

I’ve suggested several times in this series that, in thinking of the application of the Commandments, which are mostly couched in the negative, we should think of the positive meaning – that we should go to the opposite. Not only avoid the sin, but practice its antidote. In this case to learn and practise contentment. To be content with ourselves and be pleased to be ourselves and where we are. And not to be consumed – eaten up – by what others have. 

Lord give us that grace. Write all these your laws in our hearts we beseech you.